- Two apples a day ‘keeps heart doctor away’
- Where did the story come from?
- What kind of research was this?
- What did the research involve?
- What were the basic results?
- How did the researchers interpret the results?
- Links to the science
- Health Benefits of Apples and 4 Other Cholesterol-Lowering Foods
- Thomas Rhett to perform at BB&T Pavilion
Two apples a day ‘keeps heart doctor away’
‘Just two apples a day could cut risk of heart disease by cutting cholesterol levels’, the Daily Mail tells us.
The news follows a trial in which post-menopausal women who ate either dried apples or prunes (dried plums) every day for a year had their blood cholesterol measured regularly. Researchers found that cholesterol levels were significantly lower in the women who ate dried apples than those who ate dried plums, but only at six months, not at any other time they were measured.
Before Granny Smith rushes out to buy a pound of pippins, it is important to remember that though women who ate dried apples had a reduction in their cholesterol levels, the study only found significant differences between their cholesterol levels and those in the prune group at six months.
This relatively small trial also suffered from high drop-out rates, which limits the reliability of results as the women who dropped out may have had different results to those who stayed in the trial. The high drop-out may also suggest that eating a daily dose of dried fruit for a year may not be to everyone’s taste.
While high cholesterol is a known risk factor for heart disease, the media have assumed that this difference in cholesterol will cut risk of heart disease, and we cannot be certain that this would be the case.
Nevertheless, the study supports the general health message that fruit is an important part of a healthy, balanced diet. Together with a healthy lifestyle and regular physical activity, this is the best way to stay healthy and reduce the risk of heart disease.
Where did the story come from?
The study was carried out by researchers from The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and other institutions in the US. It was funded by the National Research Initiative of the US Department of Agriculture Cooperative State Research, Education, and Extension Service. The plums were provided by the California Dried Plum Board.
The study was published in the peer-reviewed Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics.
The Mail highlights the benefits of two apples a day, but doesn’t make it clear that this study was of dried apples, not fresh apples (though the study does say that the 75g is about the equivalent of two medium sized apples). Also, while the reported drop in cholesterol is accurate, we don’t know that this will definitely cut the risk of heart disease.
What kind of research was this?
This was a randomised controlled trial which aimed to see whether eating dried apples or plums reduced risk factors for cardiovascular disease in post-menopausal women. The authors say that prior animal and human research studies have demonstrated that polyphenolic compounds and fibre in certain foods can regulate fat metabolism and reduce the production of inflammatory molecules in the body – factors that are associated with risk of cardiovascular disease. As apples are a good source of polyphenolic compounds and fibre, the researchers aimed to investigate their effect on these factors in their study.
A randomised controlled trial is the best way of investigating whether a particular intervention (in this case dried apple) affects an outcome (cholesterol and inflammatory molecules) compared to a comparator (dried plum). With any self-administered food trial, making sure people eat what they are supposed to may be an issue.
What did the research involve?
The researchers recruited post-menopausal women from Tallahassee, Florida, during 2007 to 2009. Eligible women were not using hormone replacement therapy (HRT), and had not received any other drug treatments, including cholesterol-lowering medications, for at least the past three months. Researchers also excluded women who were heavy smokers or who had chronic disease, including cardiovascular disease and diabetes.
The women underwent a medical and nutrition assessment and 160 were included in the trial. The women were randomly assigned to eat either 75g of dried apple daily or 100g of dried plum daily for 12 months. To monitor compliance, the women were given calendars and asked to mark the days they missed eating the apple or plum and to record or return any unused portion.
At the start of the study, and then at 3, 6 and 12 months, fasting blood samples were taken in order to measure cholesterol and inflammatory molecules in the blood. At the same time points body measurements, physical activity recall and seven-day dietary recall were also obtained.
Women were not blinded to their allocation (as they obviously knew if they were eating apples or plums), but researchers analysing the results were.
What were the basic results?
At three months 82% of the apple group and 73% of the plum group had continued the trial and were analysed. At six months this dropped to 68% of both groups, and at the final 12-month follow-up had dropped to 63% of both groups. A common reason for drop-out was non-compliance with eating the dried fruits.
In the apple group:
- at three months total cholesterol had reduced by 9% and LDL cholesterol (sometimes called ‘bad’ cholesterol) by 16%
- at six months total cholesterol had reduced by 13% and LDL cholesterol by 24%
- at 12 months, total cholesterol was still 13% down and LDL cholesterol was still 24% down
These reductions were large enough to be statistically significant.
In the plum group, total cholesterol was reduced by 3.5% and LDL ‘bad’ cholesterol by 8% at 12 months. This reduction was not large enough to be statistically significant (the difference could have just occurred by chance).
The only difference found between the groups was that total cholesterol levels were significantly lower in the dried apple group compared with the dried plum group at six months, but not at 3 or 12 months. There was no difference between dried apples and dried plums in LDL ‘bad’ cholesterol at any time-point.
Both dried fruits reduced the inflammatory molecule C-reactive protein in the women’s blood. Levels of c-reactive protein were significantly lower in the dried plum group compared with the dried apple group at three months.
The average body weight of women in both groups was not significantly different at study start, or at 3, 6, and 12 months. Analysis of the seven-day dietary recall and physical activity recall also found no between-group differences in reported food intakes and physical activity levels at any time-points.
How did the researchers interpret the results?
The researchers conclude that there was a significant difference between the dried apple and dried plum groups only in total cholesterol level at six months. However, within-group comparisons showed greater reductions in cholesterol levels in the apple group as early as 3 months. Both dried apple and dried plum reduced certain inflammatory markers.
This 12-month trial in 160 post-menopausal women has found that eating dried apples daily reduces total cholesterol and LDL ‘bad’ cholesterol at three months and further reduces it at six months. Many news stories on the benefits of fruits and vegetables are based on laboratory or animal studies using chemicals extracted from fruits and not fruits themselves. This study is a commendable attempt to use a robust study design to look at the direct effects of fruit in people. Its strengths are that it is a well-designed, randomised controlled trial, which made careful attempts to consider the potential confounders of physical activity and other diet, and to assess the compliance of women to their assigned group.
However, there are limitations to this trial to be considered before post-menopausal women rush out to buy dried apples:
- Though within their group the women eating the apple had greater reductions in their cholesterol, the only significant difference between the groups was a greater reduction in total cholesterol at the six-month time point only.
- The trial was relatively small to start with and suffered from high drop-out rates: only 68% of women in both groups continued to six months and this had dropped to only 63% at 12 months. This limits the reliability of results, as the women who dropped out could have had differing results.
- Most importantly, though high cholesterol is a known risk factor for cardiovascular disease, the study has not measured health outcomes, so although the media may have assumed that this difference in cholesterol will cut risk of heart disease, we do not know that this would definitely be the case.
- The study only included post-menopausal women, and findings may not apply to children, men or pre-menopausal women.
Nevertheless the study supports the general health message that a balanced diet high in fruit and vegetables, a healthy lifestyle and regular physical activity, are the best ways to stay healthy and reduce the risk of heart disease.
Analysis by Bazian
Edited by NHS Website
Links to the science
Chai SC, Hooshmand S, Saadat RL, et al.
Daily Apple versus Dried Plum: Impact on Cardiovascular Disease Risk Factors in Postmenopausal Women. Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics
Published online, July 26, 2012
Health Benefits of Apples and 4 Other Cholesterol-Lowering Foods
We’ve heard the phrase, “An apple a day keeps the doctor away” and yes, we all know fruit is healthy, but is the saying literal? Apparently so!
According to new research from Florida State University apples are truly a “miracle fruit” that lower cholesterol to fight heart disease, the #1 killer of men and women. Apple antioxidants and pectin (the sticky part of fruit used to make all-fruit jams and jellies) lower “bad” LDL cholesterol (think L is for lousy) and fight inflammation, a known trigger of premature aging and disease.
In the new study 160 women added a daily dose of dried apples to their diet for a year. Blood samples taken at 3, 6 and 12 months showed results scientists described as “incredible” – by 6 months LDL plummeted by 23 percent while HDL levels, the “good” type (think H is for happy) rose about 4 percent, and markers for inflammation dropped. What’s more, the extra 240 calories per day did not lead to weight gain; in fact, the women lost on average a little over 3 pounds. Pretty impressive! But apples aren’t the only ticker-protecting food. Here are four more:
In addition to reducing inflammation this herb, affectionally known as the stinking rose, also fights oxidation. Examples of oxidation you’re probably familiar with are when a sliced apple turns brown or when metal rusts. When the “bad” LDL cholesterol in the body gets oxidized, it creates a domino effect that ups the risk of heart disease. The antioxidants in garlic fight oxidation to protect the blood vessels from being damaged. Definitely worth the need to carry breath mints.
A recent study found that a natural substances in broccoli, Brussels sprouts, cabbage and kale protect the tiny bends and branches in your blood vessels, the areas most prone to cholesterol build-up and inflammation. It just so happens that previous studies have found that those exact same veggies contain natural detoxers that deactivate cancer-causing substances and stop or slow the growth of existing cancer cells.
A study in overweight men and women found that adding one serving of strawberries to an unhealthy meal (in this case a bagel with cream cheese and whole milk) prevented a post-meal rise in the oxidation of “bad” LDL cholesterol, the process that triggers hardening of arteries and ups the risk of heart attack and stroke. It also reduced post-meal inflammation, lowered insulin levels and relaxed blood vessels, to lower blood pressure and reduce stress on the heart.
There’s plenty of research on the heart protective effects of dark chocolate. In one study that tracked nearly 32,000 Swedish women for 9 years those who ate an average of one to two servings each week had a 32 percent lower risk of developing heart failure. In another heart attack survivors who enjoyed it just twice a week over a two-year period cut their risk of dying from heart disease threefold. I’m such a fan I made a ‘daily dark chocolate escape’ a mandatory part of the eating plan in my newest book. I like to think of it as giving your heart a hug!
Cynthia Sass is a registered dietitian with master’s degrees in both nutrition science and public health. Frequently seen on national TV she’s a SHAPE contributing editor and nutrition consultant to the New York Rangers and Tampa Bay Rays. Her latest New York Times best seller is Cinch! Conquer Cravings, Drop Pounds and Lose Inches.
- By Cynthia Sass
Along with Italian colleagues, the research team believe the consumption of two apples a day in the diet can improve CVD risk factors and reducing total and low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol.
“Our findings show clear cause and effect between two Renetta Canada apples into normal diets and improved CVD risk factors, by reducing total cholesterol (TC), LDL cholesterol, and increasing microvascular vasodilation, in healthy subjects with mildly raised serum cholesterol concentrations,” the team says.
“Dose- and structure-response studies are necessary to explore the potential mechanisms, which are likely to involve bile acid (BA) signalling and/or small phenolic acids derived from apple polyphenols, both linked to gut microbiota metabolism.”
The randomised, controlled, crossover trial, which featured in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, received a mixed response from fellow academics, who point to the study’s short duration and size as two drawbacks to the research.
Results not definitive
“The trial, whilst well designed, was relatively small in size and short in duration and measured many things, so I would not say these results are definitive,” says Naveed Sattar, professor of metabolic medicine at the University of Glasgow. “Larger, longer studies are required to confirm and should be done.”
“The results of this study are of interest – any simple dietary changes that help lower cholesterol are to be welcomed, even if the reduction is relatively modest at around 4%, which is not sufficient to treat high cholesterol in many people at elevated risk of heart disease.”
Statins, schmatins. Just eat one whole apple a day and you can cut your cholesterol.
By a lot.
Or so a new study from Ohio State University suggests. A group of healthy older adults ages 40 to 60 who ate an apple a day for four weeks ended up lowering their levels of LDL – called the “bad” cholesterol because it gums up the arteries – by a whopping 40 percent.
Wow, we thought, that old saying really is true. Plus, it’s now peak apple season – what a perfect segue from health to food to recipes. (Anyone for a nice baked apple with walnuts?)
But after more closely reading the study, published online in the Journal of Functional Foods, we realized there are a couple of caveats. First of all, it was funded by an apple-industry association. Second, it was a pretty small group – just 16 adults who ate apples, another 17 who took capsules containing antioxidants found in apples, and 18 people who took placebo pills containing no antioxidants.
On the other hand, achieving such a large decrease in such a small group makes this research not only statistically significant, but relevant because of the size of the effect. And the researchers were careful to use adults who had not been regular apple eaters – typically consuming just two a month – to offset the influence from their regular diet.
Plus, it echoes other recent research, including a study last year from Florida State University that found similar results among older women who ate apples daily.
While the subjects in the Ohio State study who took the the polyphenol (antioxidant) capsules also showed improvement in their cholesterol levels, it wasn’t as strong as from consuming whole apples, said lead researcher Robert DiSilvestro, who called the results from eating just one apple a day “a tremendous effect.”
The other good news: In the study, the subjects ate either a red or golden Delicious apple purchased from a supermarket, but you can branch out to other varieties, especially now that this fall’s apple harvest is showing up in farmers’ markets as well as local groceries.
In other health news:
Stop kissing your dog – you’re giving him gum disease. A Wall Street Journal story reports that dog owners and their pets may exchange harmful mouth bacteria that can cause gum disease and tooth decay in both humans and canines, according to a report in Archives of Oral Biology. While studies have shown that parents can transmit oral bacteria to children, few studies have looked at bacteria pets may get from their owners.
CVS Caremark prescription refills investigated for possible Medicare fraud. The Los Angeles Times reports that Medicare is investigating whether CVS Caremark Corp., the country’s second-largest drugstore chain, has refilled prescriptions and submitted insurance claims without patients’ approval, according to an official with knowledge of the matter.
Eat more chocolate, win more Nobel Prizes. A study ties chocolate consumption to the number of Nobel Prize winners a country has and suggests it’s a sign that the sweet treat can boost brainpower, NBCnews.com reports. And no, this isn’t a joke: The research, which looked at per-capita chocolate consumption and number of Nobels, appeared in the prestigious New England Journal of Medicine – but as a “note” rather than a rigorous, peer-reviewed study.
Photo: Getty Images
Thomas Rhett to perform at BB&T Pavilion
- About PhillyVoice.com
- About aHealthierPhilly
- Contact Us
- Legal / Privacy
- Staff / Contributors
The contents of this website, such as text, graphics, images, and other material contained on this website, are for informational purposes only and do not constitute medical advice.
ahealthierphilly is sponsored by Independence Blue Cross, the leading health insurance organization in Southeastern Pennsylvania, serving nearly 2.5 million people in the region, providing health news and related information that leads to a more informed, healthier life.
ahealthierphilly and its health-related information resources are not a substitute for the medical advice, diagnosis, and treatment that patients receive from their physicians or health care providers and are not meant to be the practice of medicine, the practice of nursing, or to carry out any professional health care advice or service in the state where you live. Nothing in this website is meant to be used for medical or nursing diagnosis or professional treatment.
Always seek the advice of your physician or other licensed health care provider. Always consult your health care provider before beginning any new treatment, or if you have any questions regarding your health condition. You should not disregard medical advice, or delay seeking medical advice, because of something you read on this site. In the event of a medical emergency, call a doctor or 911 immediately.
This website does not recommend or endorse any specific tests, physicians, procedures, opinions, or other information that may be mentioned on this website. Descriptions of, references to, or links to other products, publications, or services does not imply endorsement of any kind. Reliance on any information provided by this website is solely at your own risk.
Although we try to keep the information on the site as accurate as possible, ahealthierphilly disclaims any warranty concerning its accuracy, timeliness and completeness of content, and any other warranty, express or implied, including warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. ahealthierphilly also reserves the right to temporarily or permanently discontinue this website, any page or any functionality at any time and without any notice.
The website and its content are provided on an “as is” basis.